Notifications
If you're the kind of player who enjoys chasing every last trophy, hidden unlock, and behind-the-scenes reward, MLB The Show 25 has more up its sleeve than you might think. Beyond the obvious Diamond Dynasty goals and Road to the Show milestones, there’s a whole category of lesser-known achievements that can earn you rewards — from XP and packs to the ever-valuable Stubs.
Here’s a breakdown of 23 hidden achievements in MLB The Show 25 that many players miss — and how you can unlock them to level up faster, get better gear, or simply flex your completionist status.
Most players focus on their Diamond rotation. But if you manage to toss a full 9-inning game with a Bronze starter, you’ll earn a modest Stubs payout and XP boost.
Keep your starter in for the entire game without warming up a reliever. You’ll unlock a hidden efficiency badge and score bonus XP.
This is extremely rare, but possible in offline play. If you manage it, the game quietly grants a reward pack.
Exploding offensively in one inning is harder than it sounds. Achieving this unlocks a pack containing a random player item.
Stack your squad with left-handed hitters only and win a game to earn a hidden challenge reward.
Not only will this trigger an in-game moment, but you’ll also unlock Stubs and XP when done on Veteran difficulty or higher.
Control and dominance combined in one reward-worthy performance.
It’s hilarious, frustrating, and oddly satisfying. Doing it once checks off a rare hidden challenge.
If you’re brave (or crazy) enough to try this, a reward pack and extra Stubs are waiting.
The longer the game, the better the payout. This one gives out double XP bonuses.
A high-risk, high-reward move that triggers a surprise animation and a minor achievement reward.
Yes, it’s doable. Doing it will unlock special card art and Stubs.
This community-based milestone unlocks minor customization bonuses and profile flair.
You’ll need all 9 guys to cross the plate at least once — unlocks XP and a trophy.
Also known as an “immaculate inning,” it grants a one-time Stubs reward.
It’s flashy and tough to pull off, but there’s a hidden reward tied to the play.
Insane patience. Walk, bunt, or wild pitch your way to victory — this one’s a favorite among hardcore grinders.
Doing this in Road to the Show unlocks equipment boosts.
Trigger this and you’ll earn a quirky hidden badge.
Clean defense gets you a fielding-related bonus in Ranked or Events.
A reward tied to bargain-bin brilliance.
Going full nostalgia mode gives you bonus XP for creativity.
This hidden chain challenge rewards you with a rare pack, Stubs, and a badge.
If you're trying to squeeze the most value out of your time in MLB The Show 25, grinding toward these hidden goals can stack up quickly. Completing just a handful will reward you with bonus XP, unlock rare gear, and in many cases, grant you extra MLB 25 Stubs Xbox players often use to level their squad.
When you're short on currency, it's always tempting to look for ways to buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs. However, smart achievement hunting can earn you enough in-game rewards to make major roster upgrades without spending real cash. And if you're looking for safe and community-verified options, many players mention U4N as a reliable name — just be sure you're playing within safe guidelines.
Whether you're grinding through Road to the Show, managing your Franchise, or dominating Diamond Dynasty, don’t overlook these hidden achievements. They not only spice up the gameplay but also offer some of the most satisfying rewards in the game.
Montagnards Social Network